Deaf Organisations, Deaf People & Information Sharing P1
Free speech is the cornerstone of democracy and is what makes Australia what it is today. Why should this be any different for the Deaf and Hearing impaired? That’s the question The Rebuttal is asking in its latest posting, “The Pursuit of Truth‘.
A question that I agree with. Why should it be any different for us?
What prompted this post by The Rebuttal, and my post, is that the Australian Association of The Deaf [AAD], now called Deaf Australia, has removed its members forums for the second time. The first time the forums were closed, some members posted some rather incendiary remarks critiquing certain Australian Deaf Organistion. This exposed AAD to potential defamation action by the targetted Deaf Association.
After an interminable period of time, Deaf Australia [AAD] re-opened the forums, with some provisos. You know the usual no swearing, no this, no that, and respect other people’s views. After a slow start, ever mindful of getting on the wrong side of the moderators [and other respectable Deaf organisations] things got a bit more interesting.
As usual, some posters took it upon themselves to push the envelope, to which I unwittingly helped to do [that is, without thinking of the consequences, and seeking an opportunity to crack some jokes]. If you follow this blog, you will have notice some satirical songs [links below], some which were cross posted onto the Deaf Australia [AAD] forum in response to other posters setting the pace.
Among other things, Deaf Australia [AAD] has decided to close their forums to the public. It is now a member’s only forum. The Deaf Australia [AAD] President posted the following message to the forum:
Fellow Discussion Page Contributors…
It is with sincere regret that closing the discussion page to non-members has become inevitable.
The Board of Deaf Australia has time and again discussed at great length the issue of the Discussion Page and over time, we have refrained from taking drastic action such as this. While we acknowledge the value of contributors to the Discussion Page, members and non-members who provide simulating discussions on issues we hold close to us, at times boundaries are being tested and on several occasions, we have had to remove discussion threads because of potential slandering and defamation in which Deaf Australia does not wish to participate. Lately, there has been an increase of inappropriate messages and postings which has prompted us to re-assess the openness of our Discussion Page.
Discussion Page is now closed to non-members. Members may still use the members only pages.
Deaf Australia members are still able to contribute to the Discussion Page. We encourage members to be mindful of our disclaimer and to respect the views and feelings of other people who read the Discussion Page.
If you are not a member of Deaf Australia, it is a good time to join and be able to continue with your contributions. We offer you a new on-line membership registration - go to www.auslanshop.com.au and click on ‘membership’ and follow the prompt.
I have no truck with Deaf Australia [AAD], but it’s just as well that they closed its forums. I don’t think they should be in the game of hosting forums. For the simple fact that their advocacy work is going to conflict with the laissez-faire nature of forums, and the internet. The heated and pointed discussions is going to be at odds with the “diplomacy” of dealing with Deaf organisations and their constituents. Their are voices that will not be constrained.
The other aspect of Deaf Australia’s [AAD] decision, is that it raises the question of the relationship between Deaf/deaf people, Deaf/deaf organisations, technology, and information sharing. How both camps engage with technology to facilitate communication, and more pertinently, how they they share information.
I’m not convinced that Deaf/deaf organisations, both professional and amateur, are doing that credible a job of harnessing the power of the internet to communicate and share information. A good example, is my membership with Deaf Australia [AAD] which allows me automatic membership of the state branch, New South Wales Association Of The Deaf [NSWAD]. I get regular postings from the national body, Deaf Australia [AAD], but next to nowt from the state body, NSWAD.
I do understand that the resources are not always available. Too often the internet is used to bolster long standing hierarchal power structures. Harnessing email lists, public forums, member only forums, et al, as walled gardens to reign in the sharing of information, reinforcing the idea of exclusive clubs.
Of course, the internet, makes it easier for Deaf and deaf people to share information, independently of organisations. This gives Deaf and deaf people, a measure of control they previously lacked. However, engaging with organisations, is still as problematic as it ever was. Satirical and inflammatory postings not withstanding, credible postings were ignored by organisations.
The first time Deaf Australia [AAD] closed its forums, the organisation that was being criticised, did not respond publicly [to my knowledge] to the criticisms posted on the Deaf Australia [AAD] forums. When, the thread critiquing CEO’s in Deaf organisations was started, again, the same wall of silence. The closure of the forums, only has a dampening affect, and the criticisms will not go away. They will simply resurface elsewhere. This second closure, again, will not achieve anything, other than drive people away to other sites that will allow them freedom of expression.
Hence the establishment of The Rebuttal, and why I blog. This is a better option for Deaf and deaf people. It allows us a measure of independence and control.
Then again, maybe it’s the simple fact, that Deaf and deaf people are surpassing the organisations themselves, in harnessing the power of technology and the internet to communicate and share information.
Meditate on that mantra!
The Funny Pages:
SATIRE: 2 Songs - FUNDRAISING MACHINE & GIMME, GIMME, GIMME
SATIRE: Another Gentle Ribbing [It's Gentle. Honest!]
SATIRE: Don’t Cry For Me Deaf Society
SATIRE: A Gentle Ribbing [Seriously]
Celebrating Neurological Devastation Week
Deafening Silence [Ode To Neurological Devastation]
Royal National Institute of Hearing: Imagine a World Without Money
The Sickness of Deaf Awareness Week: Imagine A World Without Sound